Is Personality Genetic? Exploring the Roots of Personality Traits

The answer to the question "Is personality genetic?" is—partially. There are plenty of other factors apart from your genes that shape your personality and define who you are.

We often hear, both as children and adults, that we "look just like our mother" or are "kind just like our father." Regardless of whether we like such comparisons, they might contain more truth than we think.

So, in this article, we’ll analyze the factors that influence and shape our personality and explore the heritability of personality traits to understand if personality is inherited or acquired.

What is Personality?

In psychological terms, personality is described as a unique set of traits, behaviors, thoughts, and feelings that define who you are and affect how you interact with reality. It includes both consistent traits and changeable behaviors.

However, the definition and view on personality have changed over time, becoming more and more closely aligned with the discoveries in other related scientific fields. Therefore, it is important to get familiar with the four major directions in exploring personality psychology to understand the contemporary perspective on it.

With that in mind, here are the four distinct streams in personality theories:

• Psychoanalytic, based on the work of Freud and his followers, approaches personality as the combination of parental influences, inner instincts, and the individual unconscious.
• Humanistic, developed by Katharine Cook Briggs and Isabel Briggs Myers, emphasizes personal growth, self-actualization, and individual potential. The famous MBTI personality test is based on this theory.
• Behavioral, based on the work of B. F. Skinner and John B. Watson, indicates that personality is the result of interaction between an individual and their environment.
• Trait perspective, first proposed by Gordon Allport, is the approach on which some major personality tests like the Big Five are based. It focuses on observable, measurable traits to categorize people into specific personality types.

None of these theories is considered to be wrong or right in terms of providing the answer to the question, “Is personality genetic?.” All of them shed light on different yet equally important aspects of personality. Moreover, modern science is prone to assuming a more holistic approach to personality definition rather than insisting on one and only correct answer.

As for the Enneagram, it can be listed as a humanistic personality theory because it promotes self-discovery, personal growth, and development. However, Enneagram doesn’t discount environmental, genetic, or other influences but attempts to build on them and provide a holistic perspective on personality.

What Are Personality Traits?

Personality traits are stable and persistent patterns of feeling, thought, and behavior that define an individual’s personality. Some personality tests, like the Big Five, focus on broader personality traits such as consciousness or empathy.

Meanwhile, other theories, like the Enneagram and MBTI, focus more on the inner motivations that shape behavioral patterns, producing specific traits.

Is Personality Genetic?

Personality is partly genetic, and there is a lot of scientific evidence supporting the idea of the genetic basis of personality and personality trait inheritance. More precisely, research on the genetic basis of personality traits by Christian Kandler et al. indicates that 40-50% of personality traits are genetically based.

However, the interplay between genes and personality development is complex. While certain broad traits and temperaments are mostly inherited, more specific traits are hard to connect to genes directly.

Nevertheless, the findings about the hereditary basis of personality traits acquired through twin studies are fascinating. For example, identical twins who share nearly 100% of their DNA often have very similar personalities even when they are raised in different environments and have no contact with each other.

As for non-identical twins who share only 50% of their genetic material, similarities aren’t as striking, which emphasizes the influence of genes, showcasing how personality is affected by DNA.

In general, the research on the heritability of personality traits so far strongly points to specific broad traits having genetic predispositions. These traits include:

• Introversion/extraversion: Having extroverted parents is a strong predictor of extraversion in children. The same applies to introversion.
• Emotional stability: Susceptibility to stress and resilience are strongly linked to hormonal status, so genetic factors that regulate hormones also affect emotional stability.
• Temperament: Emotional reactivity, activity level, and self-regulation have a strong genetic predisposition.

5 Other Factors That Influence Personality

There are many other factors that influence an individual’s personality besides genes, so the answer to the question "Is personality genetic?" is more complex than you may have originally anticipated.

With that in mind, let’s address the main non-genetic factors that shape an individual’s personality:

#1. Upbringing

The attachment style and quality of care an individual gets in their earliest years significantly shape their personality. Early bonds are pivotal in personality development and can significantly modify the expression of certain genetic tendencies.

For instance, a highly sensitive child raised in a warm and supportive environment is likely to develop leadership abilities, whereas that same child, deprived of support, may grow into an emotionally unstable adult.

#2. Culture

Every culture is specific in terms of gender roles, the concept of success, and recognized values and priorities, and, as such, influences every aspect of an individual’s personality.

A collectivistic culture that values collaboration and harmony will promote the development of empathy and affect how specific traits linked with empathy are genetically expressed in an individual.

An individualistic culture will, likewise, promote different sets of traits like independence and assertiveness, also affecting how and to which extent specific inherent traits will be developed.

#3. Socioeconomic Factors

Poverty, economic instability, and hardship can create a lot of stress in an individual’s life, and stress can trigger genes to be expressed differently than they would be expressed in an economically stable environment.

For example, individuals growing up in a resource-limited environment are more likely to develop adaptability and resilience. Meanwhile, those growing up in a more economically stable environment may be more prone to developing creativity.

Furthermore, early experience of poverty may affect an individual’s values, making them more ambitious and goal-oriented, whereas those who didn’t struggle economically may adopt a more easygoing attitude toward a career.

In fact, according to the research on the effects of socioeconomic status on personality development, individuals coming from favorable economic backgrounds scored lower on the scale of neuroticism. They also showed higher levels of extraversion, openness, and conscientiousness.

#4. Personal Relationships

It is widely known that the quality of the relationship with the primary caregiver significantly influences one’s capacity for connection. Nevertheless, even if the relationship with the primary caregiver wasn’t good enough, quality connections with other people can compensate for the initial lack of quality care.

So, every nurturing, supportive relationship with other people, including friends, siblings, teachers, and other important people in one’s life, can promote certain personality traits, like empathy and trust.

Likewise, every toxic relationship dynamic can contribute to developing different sets of traits, such as, in this case, cautiousness or defensiveness.

#5. Education and Learning

Learning experiences can be especially powerful in fostering certain personality traits and are generally an important factor in personality development. Exposure to quality education fosters traits like conscientiousness and openness. Additionally, it is also linked to problem-solving skills and curiosity.

Moreover, a strong educational foundation can help an individual identify and foster their talents that wouldn’t be recognized otherwise. In that way, education interacts with a genetic predisposition, resulting in the development of specific personality traits.

Nature vs. Nurture Personality Debate

The nature vs. nurture personality debate aims to provide answers to questions like "Is personality genetic or environmental?" and "Is personality genetic or learned?".

The nature-based perspective refers to biological and genetic factors that influence personality traits, while the nurture-based approach emphasizes the importance of environmental factors in personality development.

The former is represented by Charles Darwin and his cousin Francis Galton, who introduced the term ‘nature vs. nurture’ for the first time. They believed that personality is inherited and that genes play a critical factor in shaping personality traits. Their research led to early studies on intelligence and eugenics.

With the rise of behaviorism and psychoanalysis in the 20th century, the focus on studying personality shifted to environmental influences.

Under the leadership of John B. Watson, who claimed he could shape any child into any personality type through conditioning and environmental control, this approach completely neglected inherent factors in personality development.

Nevertheless, while in the past, the scientific community was more prone to deciding between these two extremes, today, it is widely recognized that personality results from the interplay of multiple factors.

The breakthroughs in genetics, such as the Human Genome Project, revealed how genes and environmental factors are interconnected, ending this debate. The consensus is that personality traits are the result of a dynamic and complex interplay between nature and nurture, where none of the factors is more important than the other.

Are Enneagram Types Genetically Predisposed?

Enneagram types aren’t genetically predisposed. The Enneagram is a personality system that divides people into nine personality types based on their motivations and behaviors. So, this personality theory isn’t rooted in genetics but in ancient philosophical traditions.

However, since the Enneagram provides a complete personality profile, including both broad and highly specific traits, a correlation with genetic predisposition can be drawn.

As already mentioned, emotional stability, reactivity, and introversion/extraversion are genetically predisposed broad traits, and we can link them to specific Enneagram tendencies. But, besides drawing correlations, there’s no basis for concluding that Enneagram types are genetically predetermined.

Moreover, the Enneagram primarily focuses on learned behaviors and motivations shaped by life experiences. It promotes self-development, integrating contemporary insights into personality psychology.

Thus, each Enneagram type is viewed as a blend of genetic and environmental factors. For example, an individual belonging to Enneagram Type Seven may display extraversion, which has a strong genetic basis, but their intellectual curiosity may stem from environmental factors, such as education.

In general, the Enneagram offers a practical framework that supports exploring personal traits and potential for growth, taking into account both genetic and environmental factors. Its holistic perspective makes it accessible to everyone, regardless of their background.

Ready to Reveal What Makes You Unique?

Take the Enneagram test, determine your Enneagram type, and start maximizing your inherent genetic potential! Learn how to shape your environment instead of being shaped by it—use the Enneagram to unlock greater self-awareness and fuel your journey of self-discovery.

Key Takeaways

Though we know a lot about personality today, there’s still plenty to learn about the complex interplay of all the factors influencing personality traits. With that in mind, let’s round off with some key highlights from this article:

• The definite answer to the question "Is personality genetic?" is that personality is partly genetic. According to scientific research, 40% to 50% of personality traits are inherited.
• Regarding the debate about nature vs. nurture and personality traits, the conclusion is that both factors are equally important for personality development.
• Enneagram types aren’t genetically predisposed, though some correlations between genetically based broad traits and Enneagram tendencies can be drawn.

Is Personality Genetic FAQ